Every day, people make decisions about their health and appearance while wading through conflicting advice: peer-reviewed research they can't easily read, marketing dressed up as science, and anecdotal forum threads of wildly variable quality.

ProofCritic brings these signals together — scientific research, systematic reviews, clinical guidelines, expert information, real-world user experience and product information — and presents them in a structured, understandable format. The goal is simple: you should be able to understand the current state of evidence in 10–20 seconds, and inspect the underlying research if you want to go deeper.

Our principles

They shape every page of this product.

Evidence over hype

What matters is what research shows — not what marketing claims or viral posts suggest.

Transparency over black-box ratings

A score you cannot interrogate is an opinion. Every rating will be traceable to its sources.

Science and experience stay separate

Scientific evidence strength and user sentiment are different signals and are never mixed.

Uncertainty should be visible

"We don't know yet" is an honest answer. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Commercial relationships never determine rankings

Where ProofCritic earns commissions, they will never influence verdicts, grades or rankings.

Where ProofCritic is going

Five categories are live — Hair, Sleep, Dental, Skin and Fitness. The platform is built for many more.

Current status

The ProofCritic MVP

You are looking at ProofCritic's MVP — the concept is now validated across four live categories. Every score is derived from a human-verified review of the research (Methodology v1); treatments we have not verified yet show honestly as "Not yet assessed". Unknown is never guessed.

User scores and product listings are kept strictly separate from the scientific score: shopping data never influences a treatment's evidence rating, and user votes are shown as experience, not as evidence.

Questions or feedback? We'd love to hear from you as we build this out.