Concern · Verified science
Muscle growth
5 treatments ranked · every card links to its full evidence page.
Muscle growth is the best-evidenced corner of the fitness shelf: creatine and protein carry deep meta-analytic support, while the products sold hardest — BCAA standalone, HMB and testosterone boosters — have the weakest or negative results. Every treatment below carries one verdict, derived from human-verified reviews of the literature.
| Creatine monohydrate | 80–89 | Works | Oral supplement | $ | 1–4 weeks to saturate muscles | No |
| Whey protein | 80–89 | Works | Oral supplement | $$ | 8–12 weeks (measured alongside training) | No |
| HMB (beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate) | 50–64 | Mixed evidence | Oral supplement | $$ | 4–12 weeks (where any effect appears) | No |
| BCAA (branched-chain amino acids) | 30–49 | Unlikely to work | Oral supplement | $$ | Not applicable — no expected incremental effect | No |
| Testosterone boosters | 30–49 | Unlikely to work | Oral supplement | $$$ | Not applicable — no meaningful effect expected | No |
80–89 Creatine monohydrate Works Oral supplement 80–89 Whey protein Works Oral supplement 50–64 HMB (beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate) Mixed evidence Oral supplement 30–49 BCAA (branched-chain amino acids) Unlikely to work Oral supplement 30–49 Testosterone boosters Unlikely to work Oral supplement
Grey means not yet assessed: a score appears only after a human-verified review of the science. Unknown is never guessed. How scores are derived →