Evidence coverage: Meta-analyses in trained athletes (trivial effects) plus older and recovery-focused analyses with small, inconsistent benefits.
Mechanism yes, meaningful effect no — in trained people. certainty: Low-to-moderate (heterogeneous meta-analyses, small trials)
HMB plausibly reduces muscle protein breakdown, but pooled effects on strength and body composition in trained athletes are trivial; possible small benefits in untrained beginners, older adults or aggressive cuts are not consistently reproduced.
- Meta-analysis in trained/competitive athletes: trivial strength and body-composition effects (source-reported)
- Older meta-analysis: small mixed effects during resistance training (source-reported)
- Recovery-focused meta-analysis: modest soreness effects (source-reported)
- Dose/form heterogeneity (Ca-HMB vs free acid) limits comparability (source-reported)
Free-acid HMB trials are newer and thinner; no reliable responder-characteristic data exists.