Evidence coverage: One three-level meta-analysis of randomized trials comparing carbohydrate-electrolyte drinks against water or non-caloric placebo during exercise in ≥22 °C conditions.
Small, real, and scoped to long sweaty efforts. certainty: Low-to-moderate (meta-analysis of randomized trials; GRADE-evaluated)
In trials at 22 °C and warmer, carbohydrate-electrolyte drinks produce a small pooled performance benefit that sits in aerobic endurance — but prediction intervals cross zero, anaerobic and strength outcomes stay inconclusive, and the trials never isolate electrolytes from their carbohydrate payload.
- Small pooled benefit: g = 0.37 (95% CI 0.21–0.53) in moderate-to-hot conditions (source-reported)
- Benefit concentrates in aerobic endurance: g = 0.45 (source-reported)
- Prediction interval crosses null (-0.21 to 0.96) — trial-to-trial variation is real (source-reported)
- Trials pair electrolytes with carbohydrate; the electrolyte-alone effect is not isolated (source-reported)
Plain water remains fine for shorter sessions; for heavy sweats the fluid itself, not only the salts, carries part of the effect.